The iPad looks to be a stellar eReader and top knotch hand held media player.

I was thinking about getting a Kindle DX but while the Kindle lasts longer on a charge, gets eBooks a little quicker and costs a whole $10 less; it is a pale monochrome shadow of the iPad… especially since you can probably run the Kindle iPhone app without much fuss and Apple’s iBooks selection will probably be quite extensive.
Both of them are elitists who won’t play nicely with independent content producers – try to get your self published book, indie comic or movie into either one of their stores… go ahead, I dare you. It is pretty much a draw when it comes to distributing through them.
Amazon doesn’t have the decades of arrogance that Apple has built up so maybe they will come around- Apple will have to be dragged kicking and screaming to deal with the little guy. Then, once Apple gets over their bitching and moaning, they will announce to the world how awesome, cool and innovative they are to have been the first to help out the indie crowd.
I can already see the smug “Hello, I’m an Amazon. And I’m an iTune.” advertisements… then again, as I mock up the ad, that phrase plays out more in favour of Amazon than iTune.

So as a device to play back something already created on a more capable device that hasn’t been purposefully kneecapped by its maker… the iPad is an okay, if incremental, device.
But I am so disappointed by it.
If the graphic work you do is meant to emulate fingerpainting, the the iPad just might be the tool for you. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not slamming fingerpainting, there is some damn fine artwork created with fingers.
Paper, charcoal dust and the hand. You can’t get much more basic than that.
Promo for Brushes for iPad
What I am doing is setting parameters. If something like the above is what you do, well then the iPad just might be a useful content creation tool for you. It would be fine for concept art, quick sketches when you are away from your desk or roughing out a scene to send to your primary computer as reference. While there are creative uses for the iPad, they pale compared to what a non-crippled OS running full applications can do… and the thing isn’t all that much less expensive – nor is it much smaller (smaller would be a detriment in my mind anyway).
The crux of it is that the iPad will not run Photoshop, Painter or Manga Studio and it doesn’t have a pressure sensitive stylus input like a real tablet pc.
For 95% of creatives, there is nothing that this glorified iPod Touch can do for us that a tablet pc can’t do easier, faster, with greater control and much better output. There are caveats of course, there are always caveats. If the capacitive capable styli have fine enough resolution, and the drawing/painting apps grow up a lot… well then, that number may shrink all the way down to 90%.
Also, if you don’t already have the full applications on a desktop and can load them onto a second computer… well, then the $4000 or so it will cost to get a tablet pc and the applications will compare poorly next to the sub $1000 it will cost to get painting with the iPad.
Before you jump on the iPad bandwagon because of the expensive software though, I’d suggest you check out the open source programs GIMP (to replace Photoshop) and Inkscape (a replacement for Illustrator but a poor substitute for Manga Studio) as well as the free (but not open source) version of Artweaver (to replace Painter). They all have their limitations compared to the applications they are trying to replace but they are free and they tower over the apps that you can get for the iPad.
The iPad will be fine for some light weight drawing and presentation but if you have enough discretionary cash to buy an iPad- why not spend a few more bucks on a real tool that has the full creative capabilities of a computer while still handling the playback chores with ease?
Sure you’ll have to switch to a Microsoft OS to get the most out of it but come on, the OS is just another tool and there is barely any functional difference between Windows 7 and Mac OS X. My last two jobs required full time use of the Mac and I use Windows on my own projects. Learn a few keyboard shortcuts and each OS’s UI peccadillos and you should pretty much forget which OS you’re on once you get into your actual application.
And if you are a True Believer who is not capable of abandoning your OS- well there is a little company called Axiotron who can (‘till March 2010 at least) sell you a modified Macbook for $1650 or mod your Macbook for $700 – the same as the top specced iPad will cost.

I had such high hopes for the iPad back when I thought it would be an iTablet. I’ve been using a six year old tablet pc running Windows XP and moving my drawing, colouring and editing to that brought about the biggest jump in productivity that I have ever had.
I’d hoped that Apple would step in and push the envelope a little, give Microsoft some competition and get them off their complacent butt.
Instead, we got the equivalent of a Newton MessagePad with a bump in graphics and some of the functionality removed.
